Introduction – Are Risk Management Rules Changing?

Whether you’re trading FX, index CFDs, commodities, or stocks, today’s market environment is arguably at its most risky, but also, of course, with increased risk, some would suggest comes increased opportunity.

Whichever way you look at it, the most challenging time in attempting to have a positive trading outcome is when markets become increasingly headline-driven and with that increasingly volatile.

Such markets demand decision-making which must be more rapid and flexible, as in minutes things can change with a planned news release that strays away from expectations, policy decisions made and then unmade within days or even hours adding to uncertainty, or a single unexpected social media post from those in power, can and often are sending markets surging or collapsing in a heartbeat.

Old-school risk models that aim to protect capital and retain profit have always been an essential part of the trader’s toolbox.  However, it could be suggested that these are built around more stable correlations, more gradual price shifts with at least some degree of certainty about what could happen in days or even weeks.

With that traditional scenario appearing increasingly obsolete for right now, it merits questioning whether this is a market that traders who still rely on static stop distances, fixed-size positions, or set-and-forget strategies will thrive in. The reality is that they will often find themselves on the wrong side of violent whipsaw moves.

Of course, it is worth emphasising that any risk management is far better than ad-hoc or, even worse, an absence of clear and unambiguous actions, irrespective of underlying market conditions. However, being able to achieve positive trading outcomes in all market conditions sometimes needs more than just having some rules in place and the discipline to follow them. It is often not just about being a smarter trader but about being the most adaptable.

This article aims to offer some suggestions as to how to review what you are doing now with risks associated with capital protection, profit retention and missing opportunity.

What could new market conditions mean for traditional risk management?

Having given context for why exploring this in more detail, let’s examine the potential challenges that current market pressures may put upon more traditional risk management approaches that, as a reference, may not have been developed to be as effective as the trader may hope for.

There are 3 factors that seem very relevant:

1. Predictable market reactions to data, relatively stable spreads, and modest price swings are all based on some degree of certainty, with relatively speaking, little deviation, if you look at week-by-week changes in expectation beyond an occasional shift. Today, that world appears to be gone. We all know markets become uncomfortable in uncertain environments, You would only need look at the VIX index to see levels of uncertainty, not seen at such high levels recently since the early days of the COVID pandemic, Static stop placements that ignore volatility levels are increasingly ineffective, often triggering a trade closure unnecessarily in erratic price action.

It is clear that what is expected to happen next may all change tomorrow, and then again, the day after.

2. Historical asset relationships, such as safe-haven flows into instruments such as the USD, have broken down when market discomfort becomes panic. Although some assets, such as the obvious example of gold, have flourished, arguably even this has had significant intraday movements. A breakdown of such relationships can not only impact on direct trading of such instruments but also the potential for effective exposure balancing.
3. Sudden liquidity shocks that can occur around planned (and unplanned) news events are commonplace, it seems for right now, as is often the case in headline-driven markets. Price moves, either way, are often exaggerated as sentiment shifts rapidly and dramatically. Few traders want to be on top of the market and spend a whole day in front of a screen, but even being away for a few hours before checking in again can result in significant profits given back to the market without the ability to trail stops in a timely way. It is crucial that profit risks, i.e. giving back significant potential profit, are viewed with equal vigour as capital risk, i.e. a losing trade.

7 New Rules You Need to Know

#1 Dynamic Position Sizing and Exposure Based on Volatility:
Rather than applying a uniform lot size or number of contracts across all conditions, an adjustment in exposure, not only for individual trades but also across your account, would seem prudent.

In high-volatility environments, typical of headline-driven markets, stop placement and position sizing should adjust:

1. To account for wider ranges in price. Tools like ATR (Average True Range) or real-time implied volatility readings can be used to scale positions appropriately or move stops so that market noise is less likely to result in premature exit.
2. To account for not only market conditions now but also the uncertainty created by potential new headlines. As previously referenced, the frequency of unplanned market-shifting news, outside of economic data release, is massively increased. Expecting the unexpected is always a massive challenge in practical terms, but approaches such as reduction of position sizing as well as reducing the number of positions open, e.g. if you have a maximum number of six positions as your norm, then considering reducing this to three positions may be worth contemplating as an approach.

#2 Scenario-Based Risk Planning:
Perhaps current risk planning merits that traders think in possibilities, not certainties. For each trade, maybe traders should be asking the question, “What happens if this trading idea doesn’t work? “What happens if there is a significant change in tariff policy once the US wakes up?” Can I trust previous significant key price levels to hold?

Planning responses for different outcomes can mean the difference between a controlled exit and a catastrophic loss.

#3 Exposure Risk Awareness Over Single Trade Focus:
It’s easy to focus risk management on a single trade. However, if you’re long AUDUSD and EURJPY, short the VIX, long copper futures CFD, and long mining stocks due to technical entries, your real exposure is heavily tied to a continuation of a “risk on” sentiment.  If there is a sudden change in this sentiment, you potentially have portfolio exposure that could result in losses across five positions simultaneously.

See your risk as this and perhaps not only, as suggested before, both setting a maximum number of trades but also being aware of “risk on” of ‘risk-off’ exposure.

#4 Watch Stop Placement where others will be looking for them (and take advantage of this too!):
Stop-losses placed at obvious technical levels (previous highs, lows, round numbers) are increasingly vulnerable in fast-moving markets. Experienced and institutional, as well as “stop hunters”, can and will exploit this, particularly in markets as they are now. Be extra vigilant to not only stay away from such levels, but also perhaps give a little more space away from them to account for increased volatility, potentially wider spreads and slippage.

#5 Accessibility, Notifications, and Rapid Response:

It is prudent that traders make sure they use the system tools that are available. These may include alerts on price levels, automated system trailing stops, as well as what you would normally use with stops and take profits.
With pending orders, it may well be worth considering just giving a little more space to where you place orders to account for greater volatility, and perhaps it is worth giving up a few pips to be more certain of a price breakout, for example (as well as having time limits on these).

Be aware that times such as these merit perhaps a few more frequent visits to your computer screen than may be your normal access. If this is not possible, then again, perhaps look at what and how you are trading, and not only be aware of the risks but temper your positions accordingly.

#6 Flexibility in Strategy Selection:
In hyper-volatile periods, not all strategies remain valid.

Traditionally, in such times, breakout systems are thought to have a better chance of thriving (although false breakouts may be common – see above for pending order placement), while mean-reversion systems may often produce fewer desirable outcomes.

However, there are often choppy periods of range-bound consolidation where, in reality, breakout strategies can suffer.

Today’s trader must constantly assess, sometimes multiple times during the trading day, whether the current market conditions align with their strategy style and if not, either adapt, step back from markets, or switch approach.

Getting that overall big picture through looking at longer timeframes is arguably always important, but even more so in the current market state.

#7 Psychological Capital Protection:
It would be amiss to discuss these sorts of markets without referencing the potential psychological toll.

Every trader has a breaking point where emotional control falters. Protecting financial capital has obviously been a major theme of this article, but protecting psychological capital, i.e. the ability to make rational decisions after a loss, is just as critical AND of course, the point at which you recognise that such a level has been reached.

Establishing maximum daily or weekly loss limits, having mandatory time-outs after big losses (and arguably big wins too), and owning that you are straying from emotional discipline are all practical steps that can be taken.

The risk is that market risk spirals, a failure to adjust and set such levels can be very damaging as the market sucks you in and poor decision take aver, don’t put yourself at risk destroy months of progress in a few days of undisciplined, emotionally driven trading.

Conclusion: The REAL Trader’s Edge in a Volatile World

In a market state where we can see dramatic price shifts within seconds, rigid risk management approaches need to be reviewed.

Flexibility, awareness, and using the system tools to have access to assist in monitoring and taking actions are not a luxury but arguably a necessity.

Protecting your capital and reducing profit risk today isn’t simply about setting a stop and a take profit, then hoping for the best; it’s about building dynamic, responsive systems that take into account increased uncertainty and volatility in headline-driven price moves.

Making adjustments in your behaviour, your trading systems and of course keeping an eye on your own decisions are all paramount to not only survive but to give yourself to thrive in markets such as these.

Many of the approaches referenced throughout this article are not particularly complex, most are very simple in fact.

As always, you have choices to make.

Ready to start trading?

Try free demo Open account