News & analysis
News & analysis

The Silent Indicators: Market Signals Most Traders Miss

25 March 2025 By Mike Smith

Share

Introduction

In the constant pursuit of market edge, traders often find themselves crowded into the same analytical spaces, watching identical indicators and acting on similar signals. 

This collective attention of market participants potentially creates a paradox: the more traders follow conventional signals, the less effective these signals become.

 While price action, volume, moving averages, and oscillators dominate trading screens worldwide, beneath the visible surface of market activity lies a rich ecosystem of “silent indicators” that often telegraph significant moves long before they materialize in price.

The financial markets do not exist as isolated entities for specific assets but rather as an interconnected web where currencies influence commodities, bonds telegraph equity movements as obvious examples. 

Understanding these cross-market relationships enables traders to assemble a more complete market picture and recognise the early warning signs that often precede major moves. This is not an exhaustive list but aims to cover some of the key factors that also offer an opportunity of accessibility for the retail trader. I have suggested some sources that may be useful.

This article explores these potentially overlooked signals across multiple asset classes, providing traders with a framework to identify market shifts before they become apparent to the majority. 

Section 1: Institutional Footprints

Volume Profile Analysis

  • Core Concept: Volume profile analysis examines how trading volume distributes across price levels rather than just time periods, revealing where significant transactions occurred and potentially where institutional interest exists.
  • Point of Control Significance: The price level with the highest trading volume (Point of Control) often acts as a magnet during future trading sessions, as this represents the price where most transactions were agreed upon.
  • Volume Nodes and Gaps: Areas with sparse trading volume often become “vacuum zones” where price can move rapidly when entered, while high-volume nodes frequently act as support/resistance.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView Volume Profile indicator (free/premium)
    • Sierra Chart volume profile tools (subscription)
    • Tradovate volume profile tools (subscription)

Open Interest Changes in Futures and Options

  • Core Concept: Open interest represents the total number of outstanding contracts in derivatives markets. Changes in open interest, when combined with price movement, provide insights into whether new money is entering a trend or positions are being closed.
  • Confirmation Signals: Rising prices with rising open interest confirms bullish momentum (new buyers entering); falling prices with rising open interest confirms bearish momentum (new sellers entering).
  • Warning Signals: Rising prices with falling open interest suggests a weakening trend (shorts covering); falling prices with falling open interest suggests a weakening downtrend (longs liquidating).
  • Options Open Interest Concentration: Unusual accumulation of open interest at specific strike prices often indicates institutional positioning and can create price magnets or barriers.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • CME Group open interest data (free)
    • TradingView futures open interest indicators (free/premium)
    • Barchart.com options open interest data (free/premium)
    • CBOE options volume and open interest (free)

Commitment of Traders Analysis

  • Core Concept: The Commitment of Traders (COT) report breaks down the holdings of different trader categories (commercial, non-commercial, small speculators) in futures markets, revealing how different market participants are positioned.
  • Commercial vs. Speculator Divergence: When commercial hedgers (smart money) and speculators (often trend-followers) show extreme position differences, it often signals potential market turning points.
  • Historically Significant Extremes: Comparing current positioning to historical extremes provides context—when any group reaches unusual net long or short positions, mean reversion often follows.
  • Multi-Market Applications: COT data covers currencies, commodities, bonds, and equity index futures, allowing for cross-market analysis and early warning of sentiment shifts.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • CFTC COT reports (free, weekly)
    • Investing.com COT data visualizations (free)
    • BarcChart.com COT charts (free/premium)
    • TradingView COT indicators (community scripts, free)

Section 2: Sentiment Indicators Beyond the Headlines

Market Internals Across Asset Classes

  • Core Concept: Market internals measure the underlying strength or weakness of a market beyond just the headline index price. These include advance-decline lines, new highs vs. new lows, and percentage of assets above moving averages.
  • Breadth Divergences: When market indices make new highs while internals weaken (fewer stocks participating in the advance), it often signals deteriorating market health before price confirms.
  • Confirming Strength: Strong internals during consolidations or minor pullbacks often indicate underlying buying pressure and increase the probability of continuation.
  • Cross-Asset Applications: This concept applies beyond stocks—measuring the percentage of commodities in uptrends, currencies strengthening against the dollar, or global markets above their moving averages provides comprehensive market health metrics.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • StockCharts.com market breadth indicators (free/subscription)
    • TradingView breadth indicators (free/premium)
    • Investors.com market pulse data (subscription)
    • DecisionPoint breadth charts (StockCharts subscription)

Retail vs. Institutional Sentiment Divergence

  • Core Concept: When retail traders’ sentiment significantly diverges from institutional positioning, the smart money view typically prevails. This divergence creates opportunities for contrarian traders.
  • Retail Sentiment Gauges: Social media sentiment, trading app popularity rankings, and retail-focused brokerage positioning data reveal retail trader enthusiasm.
  • Institutional Positioning Clues: Fund flow data, professional survey results, and positioning metrics from prime brokers indicate institutional sentiment.
  • Warning Signs: Extreme retail enthusiasm combined with institutional caution often precedes corrections; retail pessimism with institutional accumulation frequently precedes rallies.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • AAII Investor Sentiment Survey (free)
    • TradingView Social Sentiment indicator (free)
    • CNN Fear & Greed Index (free)

Volatility Term Structure

  • Core Concept: The volatility term structure shows expected volatility across different time frames. The relationship between near-term and longer-term volatility expectations provides insights into market stability.
  • Contango vs. Backwardation: Normal markets show higher volatility expectations for longer time frames (contango); inverted term structure (backwardation) signals immediate market stress and often precedes significant moves.
  • Term Structure Shifts: Sudden changes in the volatility curve often precede major market regime changes, even when the headline volatility index appears stable.
  • Cross-Asset Volatility Comparison: Comparing volatility in related markets (e.g., currency volatility vs. equity volatility) can reveal building stress in one market before it impacts others.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • CBOE VIX term structure (free)
    • VIX futures curve data on futures exchanges (free)
    • TradingView VIX futures spread indicators (free/premium)
    • LiveVol (CBOE) volatility data (free/subscription)

Section 3: Cross-Asset Correlations

Currency/Commodity Relationships

  • Core Concept: Specific currency pairs often move in tandem with related commodities due to economic linkages—AUD with iron ore and coal, CAD with oil, NOK with natural gas, etc. Divergences between the two can signal changing fundamentals.
  • Leading Indicators: Currency moves frequently lead commodity price movements due to currency markets’ greater liquidity and sensitivity to changing economic conditions and capital flows.
  • Correlation Breakdowns: When previously correlated assets decouple, it often signals a fundamental shift in market dynamics or the emergence of a new driving factor.
  • Practical Trading Applications: Monitoring currency moves can provide early warning for commodity traders; likewise, significant commodity price changes may predict currency movements before they occur.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView correlation indicator (free/premium)
    • Investing.com currency and commodity charts (free)
    • MacroMicro correlation tables (free/subscription)
    • FXStreet correlation tables (free)

Real-World Example: A clear illustration occurred in February 2025 when the Australian dollar (AUD) began weakening against major currencies despite stable iron ore prices. Traditionally, these two assets move in tandem due to Australia’s position as a major iron ore exporter. Traders monitoring this relationship noticed the divergence—the currency was signalling weakness while the commodity remained strong. 

Within three weeks, iron ore prices began a significant decline that the currency had “predicted” through its earlier weakness. Commodity traders who observed this currency leading indicator had already reduced exposure before the commodity price drop materialized.

Bond Market Leading Indicators

  • Core Concept: Fixed income markets often signal economic changes before they appear in other asset classes. Key relationships like yield curve steepness, credit spreads, and bond market volatility frequently lead equity, commodity, and currency moves.
  • Yield Curve Analysis: The relationship between short-term and long-term interest rates reflects economic expectations—flattening/inverting curves often precede economic slowdowns, while steepening curves frequently signal growth and inflation.
  • Credit Spread Warnings: Widening spreads between government bonds and corporate debt indicate increasing risk aversion; sector-specific spread widening often precedes industry-specific equity weakness.
  • Treasury-Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS): The break-even inflation rate derived from conventional Treasuries and TIPS reveals market inflation expectations, often leading commodity price trends.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data) yield curve data (free)
    • Bond charts and indicators (most CFD trading platforms)
    • Investing.com bond market data (free)
    • Koyfin yield curve visualization (free/subscription)

Real-World Example: In mid-2024, while most equity markets were still rallying, high-yield corporate bond spreads began widening subtly against Treasury bonds. This credit spread expansion wasn’t making headlines, but traders monitoring these relationships noted the growing risk aversion in fixed income markets. 

Within six weeks, this “silent indicator” from the bond market manifested in equity markets as increased volatility and sector rotation away from higher-risk growth stocks. Traders who recognized this early warning sign had already adjusted their equity exposure and positioned defensively before the shift became obvious in stock prices.

Dollar Index Correlations

  • Core Concept: The U.S. Dollar Index (DXY) has strong inverse relationships with many asset classes. Understanding dollar strength or weakness provides context for moves in commodities, emerging markets, and multinational companies.
  • Commodity Price Impacts: Most commodities are priced in dollars, creating an inherent inverse relationship—dollar strength typically pressures commodity prices, while dollar weakness often supports them.
  • Global Risk Sentiment Indicator: In risk-off environments, the dollar frequently strengthens as capital seeks safety; in risk-on periods, it often weakens as capital flows to higher-yielding assets.
  • Correlation Phases: The dollar’s correlation with other assets isn’t static—it shifts based on market regimes and dominant narratives. Identifying the current correlation regime is essential for proper interpretation.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView dollar index charts (free/premium)
    • Finviz.com correlation matrix (free)
    • Investing.com currency correlation tables (free)
    • MarketWatch dollar index data (free)

Section 4: Time-Based Indicators

Trading Session Patterns and Handoffs

  • Core Concept: Global markets operate in a continuous cycle as trading activity moves from Asia to Europe to North America. How markets behave during these handoffs and how one region responds to another’s moves provides valuable context.
  • Overnight Price Action Significance: Gaps between sessions often reveal institutional positioning; consistent patterns of overnight strength or weakness can identify the dominant trading region driving a trend.
  • Regional Divergences: When markets in different regions begin showing different directional biases (e.g., Asian markets weak while European markets strengthen), it often signals changing global capital flows and potential trend shifts.
  • Volume Distribution Changes: Shifts in when the bulk of trading volume occurs during 24-hour markets (FX, futures) often indicate changing participant behaviour and potential trend exhaustion.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • Investing.com global indices charts (free)
    • FXStreet session times indicator (free)
    • Electronic market hours gap analysis on any charting platform

Market Range Development

  • Core Concept: Markets typically establish daily, weekly, and monthly trading ranges. How price behaves within these ranges, how it tests boundaries, and how ranges evolve over time reveals underlying market dynamics.
  • Opening Range Theory: The initial trading range established in the first 30-60 minutes often defines the day’s battleground; breakouts or failures from this range frequently determine session direction.
  • Weekly Range Analysis: Weekly opening gaps and the market’s response to the previous week’s high/low levels provide context for likely price behaviour; persistent testing of the same levels indicates important price zones.
  • Range Expansion/Contraction Cycles: Markets cycle between periods of range expansion (trending) and range contraction (consolidation); identifying these patterns helps anticipate transitions between trading strategies.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView range tools and indicators (free/premium)
    • Trading session opening range indicators (available on most platforms)
    • Average True Range (ATR) studies (available on all platforms)
    • Session high/low markers (available on most platforms)

Seasonal and Calendar Effects

  • Core Concept: Despite market evolution, certain calendar-based patterns maintain statistical significance when viewed over long timeframes. These patterns create probabilistic edges for specific time periods when combined with confirming indicators.
  • Monthly Patterns: Many markets show persistent strength or weakness in certain months due to fiscal year timing, commodity production cycles, and institutional fund flows.
  • Day-of-Week Tendencies: Statistical analysis reveals certain days consistently show different characteristics—some favor trend continuation while others show mean reversion tendencies.
  • Market-Specific Cycles: Each market has unique seasonal patterns—agricultural commodities follow growing seasons, energy markets follow consumption patterns, currencies reflect trade flow timing, etc.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView seasonality indicators (community scripts, free)
    • Equity Clock seasonal charts (free)
    • Moore Research seasonal patterns (free/subscription)
    • Seasonal Charts website (free)

Time-Based Divergences

  • Core Concept: Comparing market behaviour across different timeframes reveals momentum shifts before they become obvious. When shorter timeframes begin showing different behaviour than longer timeframes, it often signals changing sentiment.
  • Multiple Timeframe Analysis: Systematically comparing price action, momentum, and volume across different time periods (daily/weekly/monthly or hourly/4-hour/daily) provides context and early warning of trend changes.
  • Period-to-Period Momentum: Tracking how momentum builds or fades across consecutive time periods reveals the strength or weakness of underlying trends before price confirms.
  • Cycle Analysis: Markets move in overlapping cycles of different durations; identifying when multiple cycles align in the same direction or conflict provides insight into potential market turning points.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • TradingView multi-timeframe indicators (free/premium)
    • Multiple timeframe RSI divergence tools (available on most platforms)
    • Multi-timeframe comparison templates (available in most trading platforms)

Section 5: Integration Framework

Building a Cross-Asset Dashboard

  • Core Concept: Creating a systematic approach to monitoring multiple signals across different markets prevents information overload and reveals interconnections between seemingly unrelated indicators.
  • Core Components: An effective dashboard should include: 

1) Market regime indicators, 

2) Cross-asset correlation monitors, 

3) Sentiment gauges, 

4) Leading indicators for each asset class, and 

5) Anomaly alerts.

  • Visual Organization: Arranging indicators by function rather than by asset class helps identify relationships—group all breadth measures together, all momentum indicators together, etc., across different markets.
  • Alert Parameters: Establish threshold levels for each indicator based on historical analysis, creating a system that flags only statistically significant deviations rather than normal market noise.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • MetaEditor development of custom indicators (free/premium but requires programming skills – although these can be accessed)
    • Excel/Google Sheets dashboards with imported data
    • MultiCharts custom workspaces (subscription)

Signal Weighting and Contextual Analysis

  • Core Concept: Not all indicators work equally well in all market environments. Adapting signal importance based on prevailing conditions—trending vs. ranging, high vs. low volatility, risk-on vs. risk-off—improves accuracy.
  • Market Regime Classification: Develop a systematic method to identify the current market regime using volatility metrics, correlation patterns, and trend strength measures.
  • Conditional Signal Weighting: Assign different importance to indicators based on the current regime—momentum signals matter more in trending markets, while overbought/oversold indicators work better in ranging markets.
  • Confidence Scoring System: Create a weighted scoring system that combines multiple indicators, giving greater weight to those with proven effectiveness in the current market environment.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • Excel/Google Sheets for scoring models
    • Trading journal software or “script” code development to track signal effectiveness

Time Horizon Alignment

  • Core Concept: Different indicators provide signals for different time horizons. Aligning indicator selection with your trading timeframe prevents conflicting signals and improves decision-making clarity.
  • Signal Categorization: Classify each indicator by its typical lead time—some provide immediate tactical signals, others medium-term directional bias, and others long-term strategic positioning information.
  • Timeframe Congruence: Look for situations where signals align across multiple timeframes, creating higher-probability trade opportunities with defined short and long-term objectives.
  • Conflicting Signal Resolution: Develop a framework for resolving conflicting signals between timeframes—typically by giving priority to the timeframe that matches your trading horizon.
  • Retail-Accessible Sources
    • Trading journal to track signal effectiveness by timeframe
    • Strategy backtesting tools to verify signal efficacy for specific timeframes
    • Develop Custom multi-timeframe indicators (e,g, in MetaEditor)

Conclusion and Your Potential Next Steps

The key message throughout this article is that markets communicate through multiple channels simultaneously. No single indicator provides a complete picture, but when disparate signals begin to align across different asset classes and timeframes, they create a compelling narrative about possible market direction. 

The trader who recognizes these patterns may gain the ability to position ahead of the crowd rather than simply reacting to price movements after they’ve occurred.

As a suggestion, begin by selecting just two or three indicators from different categories that complement your existing strategy and time availability. 

For example, a stock trader might add bond market signals and currency relationships to provide context for equity positions. A commodity trader could benefit from monitoring related currency pairs and institutional positioning through COT reports.

Above all, remember that these indicators exist within a complex market ecosystem. Interpreting them requires context—understanding the prevailing market regime, volatility environment, and broader narrative driving asset prices. 

An edge in trading has always belonged to those who can interpret what the market is saying before it becomes obvious to everyone else. By listening to the market’s quieter signals, you position yourself to hear tomorrow’s news today.

Ready to start trading?

The information provided is of general nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situations or needs. Before acting on any information provided, you should consider whether the information is suitable for you and your personal circumstances and if necessary, seek appropriate professional advice. All opinions, conclusions, forecasts or recommendations are reasonably held at the time of compilation but are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not an indication of future performance. Go Markets Pty Ltd, ABN 85 081 864 039, AFSL 254963 is a CFD issuer, and trading carries significant risks and is not suitable for everyone. You do not own or have any interest in the rights to the underlying assets. You should consider the appropriateness by reviewing our TMD, FSG, PDS and other CFD legal documents to ensure you understand the risks before you invest in CFDs. These documents are available here.